Skip to content

UK edition London open

Markets

  • FTSE 10010,937.93+0.32%
  • S&P 5007,561.67-0.40%
  • GBP/USD1.3193-0.29%
  • EUR/USD1.1012-0.35%
  • Brent$95.09-0.78%
  • Gold$3,876.90-0.24%
  • Bitcoin$64,493-1.24%

Delayed · 11:56 UK

FRC fines Saffery LLP and partner £705,250 over 23 breaches in Greensill audit

Saffery LLP and audit partner Michael Di Leto were sanctioned over the 2019 Greensill Capital (UK) audit, with 22.5% off the fines for admissions.

The Financial Reporting Council (FRC) fined Saffery LLP and audit partner Michael Di Leto £705,250 combined on Monday over 23 admitted breaches it called “serious and pervasive” in the 2019 Greensill Capital (UK) audit.

Saffery’s penalty is £581,250 and Di Leto’s is £124,000. Each was cut by 22.5% for admissions and early disposal, from £750,000 and £160,000 respectively, so the discounted total compares with £910,000 before the reduction.

Simon Broadhurst, Deputy Executive Counsel at the FRC, said the audit “failed to fully identify” the risks arising from GCUK’s complex operations, or to respond properly to those it did identify. “As a result, the audit work was poorly planned and often superficial,” he said.

The breaches, covering the financial year ended 31 December 2019, concern planning and risk assessment, work on accounting policies, revenue, expected credit losses and going concern, review of audit evidence, quality control and professional scepticism.

The FRC said the audit work did not properly answer significant risks, including those from revenue recognition, management override of controls and the valuation and recovery of assets. It linked this to a failure to understand the business model of Greensill Capital (UK) Limited (GCUK).

The going concern work, which tests the assumption that a company can keep trading, was also flawed. The FRC said, however, that its Executive Counsel “does not suggest” the going concern breaches caused GCUK’s administration.

GCUK was the main trading entity of the Australian-headquartered Greensill Group and supplied working capital finance to customers. After difficulties renewing trade credit insurance it stopped originating new business on 2 March 2021 and entered administration on 8 March 2021. The administration is still ongoing.

Saffery also received a severe reprimand and a declaration that its 2019 audit report did not satisfy the relevant requirements. Di Leto received a severe reprimand.

Both must act to reduce the likelihood of the breaches recurring, and both were ordered to pay the costs of the investigation. The FRC said they co-operated with it.

Since the 2019 audit, Saffery has changed its audit processes, and Di Leto has taken some remedial steps. The FRC said the effectiveness of those measures has not yet been assessed, and that the order will seek to determine it.

The FRC announced the investigation on 28 June 2021, under the name Saffery Champness. Its Conduct Committee had decided to open it on 15 June 2021. The case ran under the Audit Enforcement Procedure.

Under that procedure, which covers audits of public interest entities such as listed companies, credit institutions and insurers, the process ends at the investigation stage if the subject accepts the breaches and sanctions. Publication of sanctions is mandatory.

The decision is one of several audit cases the FRC has concluded in recent weeks. It imposed sanctions in the HW Fisher case over Liberty Commodities Ltd on 27 October and in the Deloitte case over Go-Ahead Group plc on 8 October.

GCUK’s administration, which began on 8 March 2021, remains open.

Published by Financial News

Written by

Declan Wraight

Declan Wraight spent the better part of a decade in and around private capital before he started filing copy. He read PPE at Trinity College Dublin, joined a Big Four transaction services group in London out of school, and learned how a leveraged cap table actually works by chasing covenant compliance for two years. He moved to corporate development at…

More from Declan Wraight